How Stairway To Heaven used modal scales to reach the top
Stairway To Heaven, a modal masterpiece.
Stairway To Heaven, the most unlikely hit of all time. No other tune has been requested more on the radio in the U.S.A. Before we dive into the modal works of this tune let’s look at all the reasons for why this shouldn’t have been a hit!
- The vocal starts at 0:50. Usually the cliché is that the chorus has to kick in at 0:55 latest or it won’t be played on the radio.
- The tune is almost 8 min long, that’s twice as long as the maximum 4 min.
- It was never released as single!
That’s three pretty strong reasons for not getting on the radio…
So how did this tune become so huge?
When Stairway was released Led Zeppelin was a very well established band with several world tours under their belt.
The tune was a collaboration between all band members utilizing all their strengths as a unit.
The recorder(s) in the intro was played by John Paul Jones, who also added the ascending bass line which ties the genius modal progression together.
The odd time signatures before the solo that seem to flow so naturally shows John Bonham's genius of taking something complicated and making it sound natural purely through the way he plays it.
The lyrics were Robert Plants and the guitar chords and original concept was Jimi Page’s. The tune took well over a year to complete and Jimmy Page said in retrospect: “I have to do a lot of hard work before I can get anywhere near those stages of consistent, total brilliance.”
There was a stage of Stairways birth were it was played on piano, but this was later adapted for the guitar.
Why is Stairway To Heaven modal?
So let’s start to look at the modal works of this master piece. Before we begin, remember, No one in Led Zeppelin had any idea about this stuff, it is only in hindsight that we can see these things. But by looking at it like this, we can learn from it. Let’s begin.
Usually people refer to Stairway as: it’s in A minor. Most likely they say this because the intro starts with Am, and the solo use Am, G & F, which are classic chords to solo over in A minor. All Along The Watchtower for example use the same progression. But actually, it’s not in A minor, it’s in A minor, A Dorian and A Melodic Minor. The majority of the tune is in A Dorian and A Melodic Minor.
Using the DIY TAB in The Guitar Conspiracy 2.0 we see how two keys are notated through out: C major (A minor/Aeolian) and G major (A Dorian).
The vocal melody however never hits the 6th interval, it completely stays away from it leaving the chords to move between these two keys giving the tune several modal interchanges and by doing this drives the track forward.
The second chord, an Am with an added 9th use the ascending bass lines G# and by doing this we are either in Harmonic minor or Melodic minor. The G# acting as a major 7th in relation to A.
The third chord, a C/G could either be in the key of G, so a IV/I or in the key of C as a I/V.
The fourth chord, a D/F# or a Bm7/F# carries on the ascending bassline and indicates that we no longer can be in Am or A harmonic minor, we have to be in the key of G here due to the F#.
The fifth chord, a Fmaj7 however tells us we can’t be in G major anymore, we have to be in C, Fmaj7 acting as the IVmaj7 chord.
These chords can therefore only be seen as modal, giving us:
Chord 1, A Dorian (or A Aeolian)
Chord 2, A Melodic Minor (A Dorian with a maj7)
Chord 3, A Dorian (or A Aeolian)
Chord 4, A Dorian
Chord 5, A Aeolian
Chord 6, A Aeolian (or A Dorian)
Chord 7, A Aeolian (or A Dorian)
The tension of this progression is paired with the very simple 8th note rhythm which makes it feel less adventurous. The vocal melody avoids hitting either the b6th to indicate Aeolian (F) or the natural 6th to indicate Dorian (F#).
The next part is the chorus (which doesn’t start until 2:15!) is in A Dorian throughout, giving it a more up-feel than Aeolian would have.
These two parts keep interchanging up until the breakdown at 5:35 where we get different odd time signatures almost every bar. The reason they don’t feel strange is because of the loose and behind the beat feel Bonham provides. If you buy the sheet music for this tune you will see how it’s notated 9/8, 4/4 etc. This is very difficult to follow so the conspiracy has written this part as a constant /8 time. Simply double the time throughout as you count and things should be much easier to understand.
The solo, as previously stated is in A Aeolian due to the Fmaj7. The opening lick (one of the two licks in this solo that Jimi Page wrote before the recording) ends on an F. This is the first time the 6th is played in the melody. Giving us a familiar release after 6 minutes of modal interchange!
The solo carries on into the final vocal section which is sung an octave up, still not utilizing the 6th.
The last vocal section is then followed by a second solo that ends on the Fmaj7 chord and Plant sings the final very drawn out line now for the first time staying in Aeolian.
Stairway To Heaven can only be compared to Queens masterpiece Bohemian Rhapsody which it ironically usually competes for the #1 spot of greatest rock tunes of all time.
So if your thinking of creating the next big thing, go modal and break all the rules that the music business have laid down as criteria’s to get on the radio, it certainly worked for Led Zeppelin!
Next blog will pick Ain’t No Sunshine apart and show how a factory worker can become world famous by singing “I know” 26 times.
-Guru
How to play I’m Yours by Jason Mraz SpyTunes version
This is SpyTunes first how to play blog, the aim of this blog is to explain how it is important to understand what you are doing when playing guitar, rather than memorizing a piece and repeating it using muscle memory.
Before we begin, let's have a look at SpyTunes version of this track so we know what we're talking abut here.
I’m Yours Background
Jason Mraz wrote this tune many years ago and for some reason it didn’t end up on any of his early albums. The tune caught the worlds attention by being a demo that by public demand made the radio. This is not the first time this has happened, music history is filled with hits that where never intended to be singles.
In the case of I’m Yours Jason Mraz must have been surprised when the entire audience would sing along to I’m Yours as if there was no tomorrow at his gigs all over the world.
The final recording is a pretty polished pop/reggae attempt that might not go down in the history of interesting production and passionate performance but no doubt, this tune is here to stay, it has become a modern classic.
SpyTunes Discover I'm Yours
Guru used to play this tune at gigs (found the demo years ago) and recorded it for SpyTunes 8 months before Jason Mraz finally released it commercially on his 2008 album “We Sing, We dance, We Steal Things”.
The guitar part and the arrangement is therefore based on that first, now legendary demo recording. Many people have written to SpyTunes wondering how to play this since the rhythm sounds and looks simple but is actually pretty difficult to play. This is because the placement of beat one is not as obvious as you might first think... So let's look at how the part is constructed.
Understanding Reggae Rhythms
Jason Mraz writes pop songs with a flavor of reggae, the easiest way to hint a reggae influence is to apply a back beat rhythm to a 4/4 time. See fig 1.
To vary this pattern you could use two 16ths instead of the 8th note. See fig 2.
Very often these two concepts are combined, like in fig 3.
For I’m Yours the basic rhythm, throughout the tune is as in fig 4.
To this concept a one has been added, fig 5
Finally, to incorporate the jazz guitar lick found on the recording we use the same rhythm and just adjust the notes throughout the progression, fig 6.
Putting all this together and we get the basic groove of the intro, fig 7.
All this put together means that one guitar is playing the whole arrangement of bass (beat 1), the guitar back beat (beat 2 & 3) and the leading lick (beat 4).
So that's it, the first lick starts on the second 16th of beat 4, you need to start this with an upstroke in order to get it right.
The secret to I'm Yours success
Now for the melody... So the chords are I - V - VI - IV. This is an unusual progression, it's very backwards, usually V leads to I, VI usually goes to V and IV usually comes after I...
So how does this tune sound so natural? The secret is in the melody, it follows the chords throughout. If the chord is a B major, the melody is only using that chords root, third and fifth, when moving to the next chord (V) it follows that chord.
This means that we get a very melodic effect, but since the chords are "backwards" it sounds new at the same time!
Use the DIY TAB in the guitar conspiracy to fully work this out. There is also a post in the forum that has the arrangement, but that is only the guitar, the secret is in the melody.
Next blog will analyze Stairway To Heaven by Led Zeppelin, did you know it's based on melodic minor?
-Guru